Data, Data, Data

Maybe what we need, before we start this journey, is a little context to add some framework to what’s to come.  

Why Sherlock Holmes?

My mom liked to tell this story: Dad decided before I could even talk that I was going to be a lawyer.  He would sit with me in front of our tv, watching “The Mac Davis Show,” planning out my brilliant legal career.  My dad – the ex-Marine, the cop, the guy who read Joseph Wambaugh novels and watched “Hill Street Blues” – introduced me to the world of crime and punishment in the hope he could turn his eldest child into Clarence Darrow.  What he did instead was instill a lifelong love of procedural dramas and mystery fiction.  

I was watching cop shows when most kids were still watching Reading Rainbow (though I watched that, too).  My dad’s job fascinated me.  The whole world of it did.  And when I got my first set of Nancy Drew novels for Christmas, I was instantly hooked by the concept of people outside the sphere of law enforcement investigating crime and solving mysteries, too.  That is what also drew me into Batman comics and media.  Sherlock Holmes was a natural next step in the progression.

But my involvement with the great detective remained cinematic until early adulthood.  I didn’t actually read any of the Holmes canon until after I graduated college.  By then, I already thought of him as a well-known friend, but the books opened up a whole new world of him.


I have a few.  In no order of importance:

  • Favorite story: The Sign of the Four. I know that’s an odd choice, but I’m a sucker for anything with the vaguest hint of a locked room mystery (it sort of is), and I find infatuated Watson adorable.
  • Favorite character: Maybe it’s too obvious, but it really is Sherlock.  He is a wonderfully complex and intriguing person, which is partly why he’s endured in the public imagination as long as he has.  And, for all the things Watson tells us about the man, there’s so much we still are left to guess about.
  • Favorite adaptation: I actually loved both of the Guy Ritchie films, and I’m not ashamed to say it, either.  No, they didn’t really have a good grasp of Irene in either, and they did completely fridge her in the second one, and their take on Holmes and Watson both was a bit more action hero than is strictly normal, but I loved them all the same.  My heart entirely belongs to the BBC Sherlock, however.  It’s just so brilliant.
  • Favorite villain: In the canon?  Millverton.  He’s a bastard.  An unrepentant bastard.  In adaptations, the brilliant evil and madness and true nemesis quality of Moriarty is unbeatable.  

What made you decide you wanted to write Holmesian fiction?

It’s that thing I mentioned up above, isn’t it?  That grand empty chasm in our knowledge about who Sherlock is.  Some people write pastiches because they want to fill in the blanks of the mentioned but never shown cases.  I write it because I want to finish putting the puzzle together.

I made him a woman because…well, because there’s no reason he shouldn’t be, and because writing about a Victorian woman trying to make herself heard in a world that doesn’t want to listen intrigued me.  Sherlock has always been a bit of a square peg in a very round hole; Charlotte just takes that to a whole new level.

So that’s that.  The real adventure begins on Monday.  At least now you know a bit more about the person leading you down the rabbit hole.

4 thoughts on “Data, Data, Data

  1. So, given your early fondness for Nancy Drew, and your wonderfully dark sense of humor, (and your interest in the idea of a woman trying to make herself heard against a worldview that fights that), are you also a Veronica Mars fan? (Hint: The correct answer is “yes.” If you’re not, why not??)


    • Don’t disown me; but I haven’t actually seen Veronica Mars. Not for lack of interest so much as…i don’t actually remember why I never watched it. I’ve had other people recommend it and it sounds just like my thing, I’ve just never gotten to it?

      It’s on the list of things to be watched, though.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s